She displays physical oddities including walking like a bunny and spitting, due to her incapability to chew. However, this theory falls apart because in both cases, neither learned how to fully speak or organize grammatical sentences. Noam Chomsky, a linguist, proposed the theory that we are biologically predisposed with the ability to learn language.
Linguistics grad-student, Susan Curtis, carried out the experiments to test the hypotheses. For example, researchers cannot determine whether Genie was born mentally severed or impaired, or whether her hindered development was solely due to her neglect.
Fortunately, for Genie language and motor acquisition can still be learned but at a slower pace than most 13 year olds. She had a large vocabulary and could understand words but she could never properly learn grammar.
The time and attention that is essential for proper development was absent for most of Genies childhood. These theories would be put to the test in one of the few documented cases in history of a post pubescent child re-entering society to be civilized and taught, language amongst other things, for the first time.
Genie requires human contact and schooling. Some Linguists and Neuropsychologists like, Eric Lenneberg, believed there was a cut off point in the ability to learn language, sometime before puberty, and once this point was passed it would be impossible to learn a language. Genie was overwhelmed with revelations of language, human interaction, and simple tasks such as tying shoes.
Throughout her new learning, Genie remained in foster homes, generally under the supervision of psychologists and linguists who wanted maximum opportunities for observation and instruction. The critical and sensitive periods indicate the ideal time frame for language and motor development, after which further development becomes more difficult and effortful to acquire.
The program was well done. The weak version said that language will not be achieved normally after puberty. Through methods used to teach deaf students, Itard was able to teach Victor the alphabet and then learn to read simple words and phrases.
Yisugei was an aristocratic leader in his tribe as well as a fierce fighter. Log in or register now. Genie is a good example of the weak version of language development. Although she can visualize it is as if she has no sight due to the severe confinement she experienced.
Improper meals were forced into her body prohibiting Genie from cognitive and physical growth. It must be noted though, that in both the cases of Victor and Genie, the subjects were both believed by some to have been mentally retarded from birth which may have contributed to that fact that they were never able to fully speak a language.
Nevertheless, she took to learning with enthusiasm and curiosity. There was evidence to support both theories but since both the experiments on Genie and Victor were ended prematurely and since doing these experiments in any other case would unethical, we may never truly know if a human can learn a language at any point in their life.
However, due to loss of funding; the project was shut down prematurely. Case studies provide us with large amounts of information, but they do have their cons. It is all free! A case study is a in depth analysis of a person.
She achieved telegraphic speechbut nothing more. Yisugei was coming home from a campaign against the Tartars w Genghis Kahn essay To prove that Genghis Khan was a great ruler, we must go back to the very beginning of his existence. It is my opinion that we are biologically wired to learn language.
Genie the Wild Child Analysis… Developmental Issues Genie is socially, cognitively and physically developmentally delayed. For these ten years of solitary internment, Genie lived a severely malnourished lifestyle.The nature vs nurture debate has been going on since the early ages, but the heat is still on between the belief that our genes dictate all our traits and the idea that rearing plays the most part.
Overview of Feral Child Genie Wiley. Share Flip Email Search the site GO. More in Psychology History and Biographies Basics Theories Psychotherapy Phobias Emotions Sleep and Dreaming Student Resources Essentially, it boils down to the age-old nature versus nurture debate.
Mar 09, · Examining Nature Vs. Nurture Through Genie. Posted on March 9, Genie represented a “blank slate” of learning, challenging interested parties to determine whether nurture or nature determined learning.
Genie became the center of studies, experiments, and investigation, as different psychologists and linguists exposed Genie to. Genie The Wild Child Essay. While the free essays can give you inspiration for writing, they cannot be used 'as is' because they will not meet your assignment's requirements.
There is a great deal of evidence from the case that supports the nature and nurture theories of language development. Noam Chomsky once declared that we acquire. Genie Nature Vs Nurture In this piece of work I will describe what nature and nurture are and I will discuss the nature vs.
nurture debate in relation to the individual development. HSP3M Essay: Nature vs. Nurture The Essay (This essay is worth approximately 8% of your final mark). GenieThe Wild Child essays Genie was considered to be beautiful, fragile, and wild.
Nature Versus Nurture; Lenneberg; Vygotsky @Example Essays. GenieThe Wild Child 4 Pages. Continue reading this essay Continue reading. Page 1 of 4. Next Page. More Essays.Download